Someone somewhere decided it was acceptable to keep animals indoors without inventing animal toilets. I was always an outdoor cat person until I lost three cats in a row to the dangers of the out-of-doors. I am now indoor only and happy for it.
Except for the cat shit.
I had a Cat Genie flushing box for about ten years and grew used to dealing with cat shit only once a week. I cannot use that flush model in my current house, so I’ve sought other solutions that minimize care to once a week.. With three cats, I’ve reached it with three boxes: A Litter Robot, A Pet Snowy, and an Old School Catbox.
The Only Cat Toilet Made
Open for more details
The box has reuseable plastic granules in it. The urine seeps down to a lower level and away from the cat, where it will be swept out during the cleaning process. During the clean, a scoop goes through the granules as the bowl rotates and it scoops up the poo and tosses it back into a grinder area. Once all the poo is out, the box grinds that up, releases the disinfecting fluid, and flushes the shredded poo and urine away. The box then dries the beads to make iti ready for the next customer.
Its only drawback is a rather major one for the 20 minutes it takes to clean: Grinding up cat shit stinks. For that reason, I generally set the box to clean once a day in the middle of the night. If you have a long haired cat, you may also face toting this revolting thing out into the yard and detangling the grinder with gloves you’ll throw away immediately. While that is not a pretty task, I find it preferable to face that once every year than to have to clean the box once a week.
You buy granules once and not again until you’ve forgotten when you last bought them, so there is no litter to buy or to carry. What you do buy recurrently is the disinfecting cleaner that you flush through the bowl weekly. The box looks like a cat box so even very picky cats will use it. It seldom smells (unless it is flushing), and you can set it to flush after every use or on a schedule that suits you. It is priced about $500, is something you can set up, and costs little to maintain in both time and money. Cats love it too.
Now, I’ve noticed they have a newer version of the flushing toilet. If I were you, I’d evaluate this one too, because I suspect they’ve correct the flush smell with this redesign. Here is that one:
Open for more details
The engineering change is a good one, but it also means you have disposable granules rather than the plastic ones which are washed, dried and reused. My guess is that the encapsulated urine means the whole grinding process is encapsulatedf and the smell is contained in this unit when it grinds and flushes. Honestly, if I were buying, I think I’d try this one. I love not having to buy granules and sanitizing fluid, but, whoof what a stink.
Rotating Boxes
These cat boxes use clay-type clumping litter and rotate to empty the clumps and turds into a waste drawer after the cat has exited. I have them both and like them both for different reasons. While none of these things is as reliable as a refrigerator, these two are both hardy souls. Both also have hard switches so that they remain on even after a power outage, something a surprisingly large number of competitors don’t do.
Both boxes have associated apps that let you put the box on your network and track its needs from your phone.
Litter Robot 4
I have tried to find a box overall better than the Litter Robot, but, so far, have not been able to do so. It has a large drum, a large opening, and cats immediately take to it. The waste drawer is large and the operation is reliable and quiet, quickly cleaning after use without freaking out the cats.
Open for more details
The globe is large enough for good sized cats, though big cats and cats with long hair will still get box-smelly from rubbing on the ceiling when the litter is full. That means keeping it clean is critical. The doorway is huge, also for bigger cats and they do send a removable panel for the bottom of the opening to stop the litter-throwers from doing their worst. It is low enough for cats to easily jump. The waste drawer is big enough that you aren’t always emptying it and they do have liners – but you don’t have to use them. . It is quiet and stays odorless as long as you use the odor filters in the waste area. It is a tad pricey, but seems to be worth it.
The alternate winner solves the problem of litter boxes in general — the dispersion of litter around and the fact that staring into a pan of cat litter simply isn’t aesthetic.
Pet Snowy
This is the box you want if you need to keep the catbox in parts of your home or apartment where you actually live. It is an attractive appliance and uses a hallway for the cat to access the litter, keeping litter tracking to a minimum and hiding the actual litter box.
Open for more details
This fabulous box for humans takes a while for cats to embrace. That is because of the way the design keeps all the litter and smells out of your way. In the photo, you see a cat peering out of the unit. He’s in a little hallway that has a mat and is blocked from view with a (removeable) curtain. Walking from outside into the little hallway, the cat takes a left turn into the box itself. The big bonus there is that it’s a large litter pan and there is no ceiling on the drum, so your cat does not rub on old ick. If your cat is claustrophobic, you can open the top of the unit and let the cat see daylight as he goes about his routine.
Litter Rake Boxes
These cat boxes clean up after the cat by running a rake down through the litter pan and culling out the solids, whether they are clumped urine or kitty logs. They are much less expensive than the rotating drum or flushing boxes and have low profiles that cats immediately recognize as cat boxes. I’ve tried several of these, but only recommend this PetSafe box.
PetSafe ScoopFree
One of my cats is 18 and pees like a grown man. If that were not the case, I would still be using the two ScoopFree boxes that i had in place for the first year I was here. The crystal litter absorbs urine surprisingly well and the rake reliably pushes the poo out of the box after each use, making it ready again.
Open for more details
It uses crystals, which do not clump and yet manage to absorb the liquid from a normal cat. The unit rakes through the crystals after the cat has gotten out and pushes the poo into a little recess conveniently hidden under that front cover area. The crystals are more expensive than clumping litter, but they are also a hell of a lot prettier and last without become unuseable: They simply don’t absorb when they get too old. You’ll use a sack of crystals a week for multiple cats (using two units) but with a single cat that still concentrates his urine, I’d expect the crystals to last two weeks or maybe even more. There’s a deodorizer pad you can put near the poo collection, but I found even without it, this unit didn’t smell much. I do not recall whether this box ran on a hard switch or a soft – it may well have been a soft switch. That said, because it didn’t clump, the worst that happened was turds started to pile up and the crystals in the middle got saturated before the ones on the edge.
I invested in a second tray so that I could wash one tray and use the other. Two of these would easily have handled all three of my cats if it hadn’t been for Pee Man. In case you’re now curious, an 18 year old cat can kill a sack of crystals in two days. That’s why he uses the winner of the Old School Box now.
Going Old School

My name is Charlie and I have no idea who you are anymore but I love you anyway. I pee like a human beer drinker.
Except for the Cat Genie, which he used faithfully, Charlie doesn’t like automated boxes. And he is fastidious. For that reason, Charlie gets an old-school catbox.
Since my goal is to make it through a week without touching anything to do with cat boxes, I had a great deal of trouble coming up with the right mix of box number, size, and litter.
What I ended up with is one regular sized catbox, with a liner in it, a small dog pee pad in the bottom of it, and recycled, non-clumping paper litter in it. I found when I put down two boxes, the other cats also used them so I was actually further behind. With clumping litter, the box became sticky cement after two days. With Feline Pine, he wouldn’t use it. (That was lovely.) The Old Tidy Cats in the red sack only lasted a day. So I was delighted to discover Fresh News.
Fresh News Paper Litter
These are little rolls of recycled newspaper. A normal sized cat box full of them, and with a pee pad in the bottom before the box liner, serves Charlie for a full week. I was pleased to find that my grocery store started to carry this so look there before resorting to Amazon.
Houseables Cat Box Liners
I started using these because you get a lot in a single box, they are reliably heavy duty and large enough even for those huge boxes. Nicely claw safe. I’ve never had one spring a leak.
Amazon Basics 22″ Square Pee Pads
What you want in a pee pad is a good plastic backing and good absorbency. These have both. Honestly, I’ve found the Amazon Basics brand to be pretty good.
To create Charlie’s magic box, I first put two pee pads down to save the floor if he misses, which is something old cats do. Then I put the liner on the box and settle it so most of the excess plastic is hidden under the box. The pee pads are accordion folded so I don’t unfold the edges and then fold the thing in half. That gives me an absorbent layer with pee pad on both sides. Finally, I fill the box to the rim with the Fresh News granules. He does fairly often poop off to the side of the box, but he never pees outside it. Those granules reliably last a week or more — even with a cat that drinks a lot of water and lets it go with regularity.










